The summer and winter solstices also fall in between these divisions. Vedic astrologers, on the other hand, use the Sidereal Zodiac system. This is based on the actual positions of the constellations in the sky where the starting point of Aries is usually opposite the star Spica. It is also argued that the tropical system is a good system as it follows the seasons and the reality of what we see around us as opposed to distant planets.
On the other hand supporters of the Sidereal system say that their system is more accurate as it follows the actual positioning of the stars of Aries. However, a counter-argument is that each constellation in the sky is not exactly 30 degrees wide. Ancient astronomers and astrologers many people were both in ancient times observed the stars above and their correlation with human lives.
Interaction across countries and continents was not as easy and quick as in more modern times. As the subject matter of study was the same, there were naturally many points of similarity. Western Astrology origins evolved from the knowledge of the ancient Greeks and Egyptians. The Rishis or seers of the Indian subcontinent defined the concepts of Vedic astrology thousands of years ago. Thus, Western astrology history and Vedic astrology origin are very different. Western astrology uses the comet Chiron and four major asteroids.
Vedic astrology uses only the nodes of the moon and the visible planets. Additionally, there are gulika and mandi as well as various calculated points in a chart that are used in Vedic astrology. The Western system of astrology is largely based on the Sun. The Vedic system of astrology places more emphasis on the moon and its positioning in the birth chart. The Sun changes signs every month whereas the moon changes signs every 2. In Vedic astrology, the Sun is actually classified as a cruel planet. The Western astrologers draw the western astrology chart in a circular shape dividing degrees into signs.
Symbols mark the signs and planets. In Vedic astrology, there are many regional differences but there are two predominant ways of representing a birth chart. The South Indian chart has a box-like layout where each square always represents a particular sign. The planets are marked in each house and the ascendant is indicated in the appropriate sign square in clockwise order. However, in the North Indian format, a box is divided into diamonds and rectangles by a pattern of crisscrossing lines forming 12 divisions.
The topmost diamond is always the first house and the house counts progress counter-clockwise. Signs and planets fill the template. The interpretation of houses is very similar in many ways between the two systems with certain points differing sharply. Vedic astrology has added far more attributes to each house than Western astrology has. One major difference between the systems is that in Vedic astrology the houses are further classified into the kendra houses angular houses in Western astrology , trikon houses trines.
There are trik houses or triksthanas, upachaya houses and many more details that have no equivalent in Western astrology. The types of aspects differ between the two systems. The planets aspect the angles and other planets. Vedic astrology uses the concept of conjunction and aspect on the opposite house as well as the planet in the aspected house. Some planest have aspects in addition to this aspect. Western astrology uses aspect patterns like Grand Trines, Yods, T-squares, etc.
Vedic astrologers do not use these concepts. Vedic astrology uses certain patterns formed called yogas. The type of aspect can be classified as good or difficult in Western astrology. The nature of the planet making the aspect determines if it is positive or negative in Vedic astrology. The rules for determining the strength and weakness of a planet are different in the Western and Vedic systems of astrology. House Meanings and Rulership. Additional Methods of Analysis.
I highly recommend that you read it, as its content complements that of this article. I prepared this article, which includes a table -- placed at the end of this article -- clearly illustrating the differences between both systems, because I wanted to focus on the procedures of both approaches, not just Jyotish, and to cover a little more ground.
I have a great deal of respect for both Western and Vedic astrology. I practice both, and find the "dance" between them exceptionally enriching. Please understand, however, that — especially when learning each system — one should carefully avoid applying the principles present in one of the approaches to the other approach, as it can "muddy the waters". When I first learned Jyotish, I was careful to keep all of my understandings of Western astrology compartmentalized and separate, until I had gained fluency in Vedic astrology.
- Ending the War between the Astrologers.
- 21 january horoscope for sagittarius?
- scorpio career horoscope october;
- Vedic Astrology vs. Western Astrology, Moon signs vs Sun signs.
Only after doing so was I able to begin to see how each system might interact with the other. Definitions In truth, there is no unified approach used by most Western astrologers. They may favor using Outer Planet transits or Progressions or Directions for their primary predictive tool, and some include additional bodies like asteroids, the comet Chiron, Arabic Parts Greek Lots , Fixed Stars, Hypothetical Points, and Uranians and Plutonians, or even adopt radically different approaches like the Huber method, Evolutionary Astrology, or Symmetrical Astrology aka Cosmobiology.
Similarly, there are literally thousands of Vedic astrological approaches, including -- among the most popular systems -- Parashari, Jaimini, Laghu Parashari, Krishnamurti Paddhati, and Shri Pati Paddhati. In point of fact, the "bible" of Vedic astrology, called Brihat Parashara Hora Shastra, is actually a compendium of independent approaches, some of which actually contradict others. This has led some Jaimini astrologers to call their approach Parashari since there are many Jaimini chapters in BPHS , further confusing the issue.
For the purposes of this article, I am focusing on modern Western astrology as practiced by many professional astrologers ignoring the multitudinous variations , and on Parashari astrology as explicated in Phaladeepika and much of BPHS. Fundamental differences between Western and Vedic astrology Zodiac The most foundational difference between Western and Vedic astrology is each system's choice of Zodiac. Western astrologers use the Tropical Zodiac, where the beginnings of the twelve signs are determined by the Sun's apparent orbit around the Earth, i.
Vedic astrologers, on the other hand, use the Sidereal Zodiac, which is based upon the physical positions of the constellations in the sky. They choose a starting point most commonly the place in the sky opposite to Spica for the beginning of Aries, and proceed in equal 30 degree segments for subsequent signs.
What Is Vedic Hindu Astrology?
Vedic astrologers, by and large, use Whole Sign Houses, where the Ascendant can fall anywhere in the First House, and each house comprises all of one sign. Planets and Sign rulerships Western astrologers use all of the major planets including Uranus, Neptune, and Pluto, and most attribute rulership of Aquarius to Uranus, Pisces to Neptune, and Scorpio to Pluto. Vedic astrologers, on the other hand, stick to the visible planets, i. Planets only aspect other planets and the angles Ascendant and Midheaven.
Muhammad Ali's birth chart...
Vedic astrologers use a different approach: each planet associates with all planets in the same house, and aspects the opposite house and any planets in that house. Are you disturbed about your career prospects? You can ask a question and settle your confusion. Vedic Astrology applies Vimshotarri Dasha system a method to time the planetary system while analysing the planetary transits for future events.
Western Astrology does not use Dasha System. On the other hand, it studies the planetary transits based on their advances and movements. Western Astrology seems to rely more on the Sun. So, the emphasis is more on psychology, the personality and character of an individual. On the other hand, Vedic or Sidereal system is a Moon-based astrology system which covers all the areas of life.
Sidereal and tropical astrology - Wikipedia
The Tropical or Western chart can provide only a straightforward explanation. Vedic astrology can be very effective and accurate yet a bit more complex. However, both Vedic Astrology and Western Astrology are worth exploring. Tanmay K. To Get Your Personalised Solutions!
Talk To Astrologer Now. Popular Posts. Rekha Birthday Prediction Horoscope Tags comparison between vedic astrology and western astrology differences between vedic astrology and western astrology vedic astrology vedic astrology vs western astrology vedic astrology vs western astrology which is more accurate western astrologya.